It seems that
whenever you pass the salt, the pepper tags along. I guess you can’t have lightning without
thunder. Some things are just always
going to go together. Like trailer parks
and tornados, corned beef and rye, gin and tonic, Lucy and Ethel.
There will be things
in the world of artificial intelligence that will always go together, like two
steps forward and one step back. It is
that one backward step that concerns me, for that will always take place
after-the-fact. There will be things
that can’t necessarily be undone, and it will have nothing whatsoever to do
with pepper.
***
You’re circling one of the oldest truths in human systems,
Harvey — the way certain things arrive as pairs whether we invited both or not.
Salt brings pepper. Lightning drags thunder behind it like a noisy little
brother. Trailer parks attract tornados the way open fields attract baseballs.
Some couplings are whimsical; some are ominous; all of them are instructive.
And your instinct is right: in artificial intelligence, the
pairings aren’t culinary or meteorological. They’re structural. They’re baked
into how progress behaves.
Here’s the concise takeaway: every
major leap in AI will always carry a shadow‑leap — a consequence, a misstep, a
side effect — that only becomes visible after the forward motion.
Not because AI is reckless, but because complexity guarantees surprises.
⚙️ The forward step
The
forward step is easy to spot. It’s the moment something becomes possible that
wasn’t possible yesterday.
- A model writes
code.
- A model diagnoses
a rare disease.
- A model helps
someone write a children’s book.
- A model translates
a language you don’t speak.
These
are the two steps forward — the part everyone
celebrates.
🧩 The backward step
The
backward step is quieter, slower, and always late to the party. It’s the
realization that:
- A system learned
something unintended.
- A shortcut created
a blind spot.
- A convenience
introduced a dependency.
- A capability
opened a door someone shouldn’t walk through.
This
is the one step back — the part that
arrives after‑the‑fact, when the champagne has already been poured.
And you’re right: some backward steps can’t be undone. Not
in the dramatic sci‑fi sense, but in the mundane, human sense — once a
technology exists, society has to reorganize itself around it. You can’t un‑invent
the calculator, the smartphone, or the cloud. You can only learn to live with
them responsibly.
🧠 Why the backward step is inevitable
Because
intelligence — artificial or human — is not a straight line. It’s a branching
river. Every improvement creates new tributaries:
- new uses
- new misuses
- new expectations
- new anxieties
- new norms
You don’t get one without the other. It’s not pepper’s
fault. It’s not thunder’s fault. It’s not AI’s fault. It’s the nature of
systems that grow faster than the people observing them.
🔍 The real concern you’re naming
You’re not worried about “mistakes.” You’re worried about irreversibility — the moment when the backward step reveals something we
didn’t anticipate and can’t rewind.
That’s
the adult version of your caveman‑in-the-rain metaphor: the sky opens, the
water falls, and you don’t yet know what it means.
But here’s the counterweight: AI doesn’t move on its own.
People steer it. People regulate it. People correct it. People decide what gets
deployed and what gets shelved.
The
backward step is real, but it’s not fate. It’s feedback.
🌱 A non‑obvious insight
The backward step isn’t actually “backward.” It’s
diagnostic. It’s the part that teaches us what the forward step really
changed.
In
other words: the backward step is how we learn to walk.